Microtransactions and Pay-per-article Schemes | YMH No. 61


Arguments For and Against Microtransactions and Pay-per-article Schemes

Could accepting tiny little payments of just a few pennies each be a way to unlock loads of blog revenue?

That is the question at the heart of a recent Reddit post, "What do you think about making money from your content with microtransactions?"

In the context of monetizing a blog, the term "microtransactions" often describes a low-cost paywall. The idea is that readers pay a small fee ranging from a few cents to about a dollar to access a single article.

Let's consider some arguments for and against this pay-per-article concept —the pros and cons if you will.

Pro No. 1: Replace Advertising

Advertising is one of the most common ways to monetize a blog. If you need proof, visit any food blog using Mediavine or Raptive for ad placement.

Recently, I visited just such a site for a sauce recipe and found ten blinking and flashing ad units, including one video preroll on autoplay. It promised to switch to "my latest recipe video" after 15 sections.

There was an advertisement at the top, middle, and bottom of the recipe. The ingredient list had an ad too. A few more ads were vertically arranged in the sidebar. There was a video ready to promote Chevrolet inserted into the comment section. And a fixed banner at the bottom of the page alternated between images and videos.

AT&T, Target, Chevy, Walmart, Zales, Ultra Beauty, Aveeno Kids, Vrbo, a local restaurant, and —as proof that I was being specifically targeted— Aviation Gin all made appearances in the rotating ad slots.

Several bloggers have told me they earn between $25 and $40 per 1,000 site visitors employing the multiplicity of ads just described. At the high end, that is 4 cents per site visitor.

Readers and publishers alike would be better off if a nanotransaction could successfully replace ten ad spots.

Pro No. 2: A Flexible Subscription

Lots of folks subscribe to content. They might have a physical magazine subscription, a Netflix subscription, or even a paid newsletter subscription.

The model works well. Publishers get paid. Subscribers get content.

Except I don't read "Business Insider" because I don't want to spend $49 a year. I don't know why it's an issue for me. I pay "The Wall Street Journal," "AdAge," and "Wine Enthusiast" without hesitation. But for some reason, $49 feels too expensive. If, however, I could pay per article via a microtransaction, I would probably do it from time to time.

It would be a flexible and functional subscription option for me. I get access without commitment, and the publication gets an opportunity to show me just how great it is.

Pro No. 3: Data

Simply put, the granular, article-by-article purchase data a blogger could collect from microtransactions might be priceless when it comes to building a content strategy.

Knowing what a reader will pay for goes a long way toward understanding what kind of digital products or services to offer too.

Con No. 1: SEO

While a paywall does not necessarily impact search engine optimization or a site's ability to rank in Google or other search engines, it can.

It all comes down to how the paywall is implemented. Is it down on the server or the client? Does it allow for indexing? Does it impact site speed? Does it create a lot of bounces? You get the idea.

Con No. 2: Friction

In Pro No. 1 above, I mentioned that microtransactions could be a good replacement for advertising. The recipe site with ten ads was difficult to use. It created a lot of friction, but so did the New York Times recipe pages, which are behind a paywall.

The experience of needing to pay for each article —or each recipe— absolutely interrupts what the site visitor is trying to accomplish.

Someone is looking for a sauce recipe to continue with the example and now has to stop and pull out a credit card to unlock the secret ingredient.

It might be the case that adding a nanotransactional paywall has the effect of killing your blog, thanks to that extra friction.

Con No. 3: It's Complicated

There are at least five ways to implement a paywall for blog content in general, and things become significantly more difficult when you want to build a paywall per article versus the more common all-or-nothing subscription.

412 South 3rd Street Apt. 609, Boise, Idaho 83702
Unsubscribe · Preferences

You, Money, Happiness

You, Money, Happiness helps newsletter creators and bloggers grow and earn online.

Read more from You, Money, Happiness

Top stories for bloggers, newsletter writers, and content creators. Please share this newsletter with one person. No. 1: Google Boosts Credibility for Creators Google's latest moves have significant implications for content creators. The search giant now explicitly recognizes individuals as content creators, assigning them titles like "Content Creator (Health)" or "Content Creator (Travel)" in search results. This new labeling is a game-changer for SEO. For the creators, it means more...

Top stories for bloggers, newsletter writers, and content creators. If there is an article you think should be included in this roundup, please reply with a link. No. 1: Fix Problems, Then Grow If you're feeling stuck, constantly chasing opportunities but seeing limited results, you're probably focusing on the wrong things. Alex Hormozi breaks it down —there are two main forces at play in a content business—problems and opportunities. Missed opportunities are exciting. They're the shiny new...

5 Ways to Find Article Ideas for Blogs and Newsletters The blank page and blinking cursor are among the most daunting challenges for a blogger or newsletter author. The words, sentences, and paragraphs would flow wonderfully if only you knew what to write about. For a new content creator, composing the first few email newsletters or blog posts may feel exhilarating. Ideas come easy. But as time goes on, knowing what to write about —what valuable idea or concept to share— becomes a significant...